Polly Hill

Duration: 1 hour 43 mins 57 secs
Share this media item:
Embed this media item:


About this item
Polly Hill's image
Description: Polly Hills describes her background, the daughter of a Nobel Prize winner and niece of John Maynard Keynes. She outlines her life as an economic anthropologist in Africa and India and her later interest in the local history of the Cambridge fens. Interviewed and filmed by Alan Macfarlane, and lasting about two hours. Generously supported by the Leverhulme Trust.
 
Created: 2011-03-30 16:08
Collection: Film Interviews with Leading Thinkers
Publisher: University of Cambridge
Copyright: Professor Alan Macfarlane
Language: eng (English)
Keywords: anthropology; West Africa; India; development; history of the fens;
Credits:
Actor:  Polly Hill
Director:  Alan Macfarlane
Reporter:  Sarah Harrison
Transcript
Transcript:
0:00:05 Introduction; reads from a script about early life; 1933 Newnham College; 2:1 in economics; 1938 research assistant at the Fabian Society and wrote a book on unemployment, published 1940;

0:02:20 Memories of Cambridge during First World War coloured life; during Second World War, a civil servant in statistics department of the Colonial Office; became commercial editor of weekly paper ‘West Africa’

0:04:23 Sent to the Gold Coast in 1952 which was a very positive experience; 1953 married; did research in Ghana until 1965 at University of the Gold Coast; 1956 daughter born which enormously improved intellectual work on cocoa farmers; research on cocoa farmers; Meyer Fortes; 1956 published ‘The Gold Coast Cocoa Farmer’ with OUP; Smuts visiting fellow at Cambridge 1960-61

0:11:12 On principle, never asked permission from higher authorities to do work as it was almost always refused; later mapped Hausaland using official aerial photos but never challenged; very bad at languages, used interpreters, but don’t see it as a weakness as one has time to take notes

0:15:42 Description of work on migrant cocoa farmers; published ‘Migrant Cocoa Farmers’ 1963, to be republished in paperback

0:20:28 Reflections on Meyer Fortes and his influence; Keynes relatives; visited Fortes among the Tallensi people in 1963

0:23:10 After returning to Ghana 1961 moved from economics department to African Studies Centre as colleague of Thomas Hodgkin (Nigerian Perspectives) and Ivor Wilks; worked among the Ga on cattle rearing and later in Northern Ghana on the same, written about in ‘Rural Capitalism in West Africa’ 1970

025:21 Left Ghana 1965 as daughter at risk from malaria; moved back to Cambridge and became a research fellow at Clare Hall (unpaid); 1965-73 did fieldwork in Hausaland, Northern Nigeria, lived in Hausa village, precariously supported by grants

0:27:43 1969 moved to house on stilts in Cambridgeshire on the River Ouse; 1973 Smuts Reader in Department of Social Anthropology, Cambridge; 1977 went to South India mainly because of dissatisfaction with pseudo-Marxism in economic anthropology in Cambridge

0:31:29 Went to Sri Lanka 1976 and felt at home in Colombo and felt previous experience in West Africa was relevant to the Indian sub-continent so decided to go to India for the following year, funded by Smuts; no visas required at that time; chose Bangalore for the climate but ignored by Srinivas;

0:35:25 Worked on six villages in Karnataka with two Indian assistants; couldn’t live in villages but in Bangalore; work resulted in ‘Dry Grain Farming Families’ 1982, a comparison with Hausa dry grain farming

0:38:10 Comparison of wealth in Karnataka with Hausaland; at the time no electricity in villages studied and water stored in tanks, not tube wells as later; grew rice and inferior millet; assistants; difference between people in Hausaland and Karnataka

0:46:35 1982-3 Went to Trivandrum in Kerala, South West India; article ‘Kerala is Different’ in Modern Asian Studies, on demographic differences with other parts of India; illness due to heat curtailed field research

0:48:32 1986 produced ‘Development Economics on Trial, The anthropological case for the prosecution’; based on the rural tropical world that is little understood by development economists; concept of subsistence farmers and peasants; position of women in Hausaland much better than in India as the former had separate economic activities from their husbands; joint families in India; farm slavery in Hausaland;

0:59:00 M.G. Smith, Daryl Forde, unhelpful; lack of niche gives little power; 1966 PhD in anthropology based on book on migrant cocoa farmers

Second Part

0:05:07 Later work on Cambridge fens; 1992 published ‘Who were the Fen People’ in Cambridge Antiquarian Society journal, a history of agriculture in the fens; Graham Swift’s book ‘Waterland’; use of census material on Isleham fen; marriage patterns; importance of public houses; population in area reached peak c1851 but by 1861 had declined by 5% in Cambridgeshire, and particularly in the fens; emigration to northern cities and overseas

0:12:50 Interest in “hinterlands” thread through work; incest and opium; Daniel Defoe

0:15:08 Study of middle-class women at Newnham and Girton c1860-1900; demographic effects

0:21:15 Memories of father, A.V. Hill and her mother; rejection by mother; mother a Keynes, sister of Maynard and Geoffrey; John Maynard Keynes and Geoffrey Keynes; own interest in poetry and art

0:32:44 Influenced by Joan Robinson, her supervisor, Thomas Hodgkin and Ivor Wilks; writing methods; own papers now at Africana Library, North-Western University.
Available Formats
Format Quality Bitrate Size
MPEG-4 Video 480x360    1.84 Mbits/sec 1.41 GB View Download
WebM 480x360    870.53 kbits/sec 656.73 MB View Download
Flash Video 320x240    504.59 kbits/sec 384.24 MB View Download
iPod Video 480x360    505.37 kbits/sec 384.83 MB View Download
MP3 44100 Hz 125.0 kbits/sec 94.99 MB Listen Download
MP3 16000 Hz 31.25 kbits/sec 23.75 MB Listen Download
Auto * (Allows browser to choose a format it supports)