Maurice Bloch

Duration: 1 hour 10 mins 41 secs
Share this media item:
Embed this media item:


About this item
Maurice Bloch's image
Description: An interview on the life and work of the anthropologist Maurice Bloch. Interviewed by Alan Macfarlane on 29th May 2008 and edited by Sarah Harrison. Generously supported by the Leverhulme Trust.
 
Created: 2011-03-17 15:10
Collection: Film Interviews with Leading Thinkers
Publisher: University of Cambridge
Copyright: Professor Alan Macfarlane
Language: eng (English)
Keywords: anthropology; Madagascar;
Credits:
Actor:  Maurice Bloch
Director:  Alan Macfarlane
Reporter:  Sarah Harrison
Transcript
Transcript:
0:09:07 Born in Caen in Calvados in 1939; family comes from two areas of France, one lot from Lorraine and the other from the Bordeaux area; the Bloch side came from Lorraine where great-grandfather was a miller; grandmother's family were from Bordeaux, were Sephardic Jews, originally from Portugal; during the eighteenth century they were very rich but their fortunes declined and the marriage with Bloch was an attempt to improve them; still have many cousins in South-West France; my mother's father was a school teacher in the Massif Centrale and her mother was a niece of Durkheim and a first cousin of Mauss, and came from a little town in Lorraine; my mother knew Durkheim quite well as a child and I met Mauss several times; he was very old by then and more or less off his head; he lived in the same block of flats as my grandparents so my grandmother used to take food to him; my father was killed in the War; he got into Polotechnique and then the French Army and was arrested by the Germans early on and was killed; my mother was a marine biologist; when my father was captured she went to the Gestapo headquarters to complain to Heidrich; of course, they never let her out and she was deported and sent to Auschwitz but because she was a biologist she was put with a number of scientists slightly outside and managed to survive; the Germans were trying to obtain rubber from dandelions which have latex and got all the biologists together in a kind of lab. nearby; towards the end she was put back with the others but was in Auschwitz most of the War; I was more or less adopted during the War by a Polotechnique friend of my father's who included me in his family under a false name and brought me up; I have remained very close to them; then my mother came back and after a while married a British biologist called Kennedy which is how I came to England at the age of eleven; John Kennedy worked at the Agricultural Research Council; my mother had other children; my mother was incredibly hardened as a result of her experience and not easy to have much contact with; she was tough and had been a mountaineer before the war; my step-father had much more influence on my intellectual development and I was interested in natural science as a result

8:15:02 First of all I went to the Lycée Carnot in Paris and then to the Perse in Cambridge; I did not like the Perse; I hated being taken to England and so I was extremely uncooperative; I was very influenced by a history teacher, John Tanfield, and wanted to do history at university; also influenced by an English Literature teacher who was a member of the 'Scrutiny' group, Douglas Brown; I was not a games player and had a dislike of cricket because it was English, though I quite liked rugby; I had been very good at boxing in France but did not continue for long in England because the games master thought it was a good idea; I became a very keen brass rubber as a child; I like music and regret never having a chance to do it; I like standard classical music plus Messiaen and Britten; I did well enough at school to just manage to get into university; went to the L.S.E. where I did anthropology; at that time Maurice Freedman was there and Burton Benedict who influenced me; also went to University College and was a fan of Mary Douglas; I liked Adrian Mayer very much at S.O.A.S.

13:52:09 I spent a lot of my time at university acting, largely in French plays; I had not acted at school; my tutor was Burton Benedict who was very supportive; I admired Firth and Adrian Mayer; I heard Mary Douglas first in my third year and thought her really interesting and exciting; I was interested in linguistics and followed lectures at S.O.A.S.; at that time I was also politically involved; both my parents were in the Communist Party though they left very early, and I never had anything to do with it; I spent time in France in opposition to the Algerian war and before the Vietnam war; I was quite passionate about these colonial wars which influenced my working in anthropology; at the end of my undergraduate course I was interested in India, influenced by Adrian Mayer; I got the chance to come to Cambridge; Meyer Fortes was setting up a research project with the French, with Germaine Dieterlen, and offered to find me some money to come as a research student, partly because he thought I could act as a kind of bridge between the French and the British; my parents vaguely knew him; I came and agreed to work in West Africa although my heart was really set on India; then the whole programme collapsed so he was landed with me as by then I had got a research studentship; he said I could do what I liked as long as it was in Africa so I went to the part of Africa which is most Asian, Madagascar; I still had a tie to history and knew the history of Madagascar

19:48:16 My contemporaries as Ph.D. students were Caroline Humphrey whom I supervised in her last year as an undergraduate, Andrew Strathern, Marilyn Strathern who was also an undergraduate in her last year, Adam Kuper, Jim Faris, Jonathan Parry came later when I came back from Madagascar; all these people have remained friends although I am in contact mostly with Johnny Parry and I like the anthropology he did; started with Meyer as supervisor but when the project fell apart he lost interest in me; the graduate students were, to a certain extent, the clients of different members of the faculty; Kuper was close to Fortes, a man called Geoffrey Benjamin was close to Leach, Andrew Strathern was close to Jack Goody; I was not close to any of them which I rather enjoyed, partly because Madagascar was between Africa and Asia; Audrey Richards became interested in me and I liked her; at the end I was supervised by Tambiah and he was the first person that I felt understood what I was doing, and understood Madagasi society; I was working in the Merina Highlands with rice cultivators; as a supervisor he was the only person who really helped me in Cambridge although I got lots of ideas from the others; I began to get to know some of Levi-Strauss's work then; I still had Firth and Adrian Mayer in the back of my mind, and the very different influences of Leach and Fortes here; my work was a combination of these two influences as well as French Marxist writers who were totally unknown then in Cambridge; for a long time I felt that nobody was interested in what I was doing but at the end, they were all interested in my work; Fortes, not much, but Jack and Edmund were interested; they read odd chapters and made useful comments, but it was Tambiah who really helped me; at that time there were notable differences between Fortes and Leach; the person who seemed most bitter about it was Jack, but I may be wrong

28:20:06 I arrived in Madagascar knowing absolutely nobody; I put myself in a cheap hotel and after a while went to look for a place to study; found my field sites in weird ways; after a while I just used to go to bus/lorry stations around the capital and just go in any of them; had a number of adventures but, on the whole, people were extraordinarily nice to me; met people indirectly like that and then I found the region where I did fieldwork; I really enjoyed doing fieldwork; I suddenly felt for almost the first time in my life that I was quite good at it; I was understanding new things which were different from the anthropology that I had been taught; I was good at getting on with people and learning the language; I had the advantage of being able to compare myself with a few totally useless French anthropologists who were around, and knew that what I was doing was infinitely better; it gave me a boost to my self-esteem; by the time I came back to Cambridge I felt, I think for the first time in my life, that actually I was really quite good; my interests were originally economy, economic anthropology, partly from a Firth background, big questions about kinship; did realize early on that the Madagasi type systems were quite different from what I had been taught; the focus was on tombs and where they were buried rather than who their ancestors are; became interested in ritual which was partly Edmund's influence; I could see the significance of the overall schema of 'Elementary Structures'; I had been interested in linguistics and that became much more important later; the link between linguistics and the social structuralism of Levi-Strauss meant a lot to me in a way that I think it didn't to most British anthropologists at that time; I had done a subsidiary degree in linguistics at the L.S.E.

34:01:12 My internal Ph.D. examiner was a rather grey figure, G.I. Jones, a rather nice man although I did not know him at all; the external was Adrian Mayer; they liked the thesis; it was published shortly afterwards and fairly well received; it was published by Seminar Press; both Marilyn Strathern and I were outside the Cambridge orbit; those inside had their work published by Cambridge University Press; I got some really good reviews, from John Middleton and Gulliver for example; I began to write other things; Jack had been doing a seminar on literacy and he asked me to take part in it; Audrey Richards asked me to take part in a thing on councils; both articles were published as Cambridge Papers and were quite different from my thesis work; I got a job in Swansea; I was married by then and my wife had a job in London; as soon as there was a job available in London I applied and got one at L.S.E.; my year in Swansea was nice, partly because I made good friends, although the department was not all that brilliant

38:49:23 Went to the L.S.E. in 1969; Freedman was still there although Raymond had retired; it was rather a poor period; Lucy Mair was still around but Robin Fox had gone; Jean La Fontaine came at the same time as me and we got on well personally, not so much intellectually; Ioan Lewis came later that year; Peter Loizos came at the same time as I did; Alfie Gell was a graduate student; I was not very impressed by the staff at that time but I was by the graduate students, like Gell and Olivia Harris, with whom I spent time and with whom I had more in common intellectually; L.S.E. took a while to pick up again but did so when Johnny Parry came about six or seven years after; Chris Fuller also came later as did Gell; think his work was brilliant although a lot is wrong and terribly muddled; the best is his book on art; his book on time is muddled; a lot of his essays are brilliant; he was somebody like Mary Douglas for me; admire Johnny in a different way as I trust what he writes; think that he is the best to have come out of the British sociological tradition; it was very good to do books together; he is also a brilliant reader and seminar leader; Raymond was good at seminars and I have admiration for his work, but I don't think he is brilliant; I was in touch with Mary Douglas and she was very generous about my work

44:20:03 The year after I came to L.S.E. I was invited to Berkeley; it was important because in Berkeley the people who influenced me were not anthropologists but mainly linguists and philosophers; I began to get very interested in cognitive science; so became interested in the work of Searle, Lakcoff etc.; began to read quite a lot of developmental psychology and also Chomsky; was not tempted to stay although I was offered a job, but my wife was not; also politically uncomfortable because of links to Marxist movements, mainly in France; came back to L.S.E.; had been interested in Marxist ideas since about sixteen and knew a lot about it; 'Marxist Analyses and Social Anthropology' is an historical book; I knew the French Marxist anthropologists and was impressed by them, particularly Godelier and Terray; I knew much more about Marxism than my contemporaries and also about structuralism and linguistics; my developing interest in them and in cognitive psychology linked to my interest in Marxism; I began to do work with Susan Carey who was at M.I.T. at that time, now at Harvard; also got to know Dan Sperber; I wrote an article on ritual which contains a criticism of semiotics called 'Symbols, Song, Dance and Features of Articulation'; it came out at the same time as Sperber's book on symbolism appeared; we did not know each other at all but there were similarities in our point of view

52:49:08 Enjoyed Ph.D. supervising and have done between thirty and forty in all sorts of areas; I was very lucky with the graduate students that I had; four of my students are now on the staff at the L.S.E.; there are others that I admire; I like lecturing very much; I write a lot and then just write notes to lecture from; I like taking new topics as a way of thinking forward and learning new things; lectures feed into my writing as well as the ideas from interaction with graduate students; I hate administration; I was Convenor of the Department for nine years and think that I did a pretty good job, in that I renewed the Department with the help of others; I felt it was a period when the L.S.E. picked up again; this was from the late 1980's to the middle 1990's; it was an exciting period and has remained good until recently; don't know what the future will bring

1:00:20:09 In terms of writing most interesting work possibly a series of articles 'The Past and the Present in the Present', 'Symbol, Song and Dance'; more recently the work on memory, the article on cognitive science and anthropology; the book 'From Blessing to Violence' I think is unusual and interesting; the latest article in New Scientist [on ‘Why religion is nothing special but is central'] - description of the argument; overlap and differences with Pascal Boyer; bookbinding; I have been very interested in child development and have benefited a lot from working with people like Susan Carey, Dan Sperber, Paul Harris, another psychologist - these people I find much more exciting than many anthropologists; I think of anthropology ultimately as a natural science while I find a lot of other work in the social sciences now what I call dissecting shadows; I am philosophically a naturalist like Dan Sperber, which sets us apart really fundamentally.
Available Formats
Format Quality Bitrate Size
MPEG-4 Video 480x360    1.84 Mbits/sec 978.71 MB View Download
WebM 480x360    753.22 kbits/sec 386.18 MB View Download
Flash Video 480x360    567.86 kbits/sec 294.05 MB View Download
Flash Video 320x240    504.58 kbits/sec 261.28 MB View Download
Flash Video 160x120    228.86 kbits/sec 118.51 MB View Download
iPod Video 480x360    505.36 kbits/sec 261.69 MB View Download
iPod Video 320x240    472.64 kbits/sec 244.75 MB View Download
iPod Video 160x120    455.17 kbits/sec 235.70 MB View Download
QuickTime (for download) 384x288    849.0 kbits/sec 439.63 MB View Download
QuickTime (for streaming) 480x360    905.45 kbits/sec 468.87 MB View Download
QuickTime (for download) 320x240    230.49 kbits/sec 119.35 MB View Download
QuickTime (for streaming) 480x360    447.04 kbits/sec 231.49 MB View Download
QuickTime (for download) 160x120    213.25 kbits/sec 110.43 MB View Download
QuickTime (for streaming) 160x120    104.56 kbits/sec 54.14 MB View Download
MP3 44100 Hz 125.0 kbits/sec 64.53 MB Listen Download
MP3 22050 Hz 62.5 kbits/sec 32.27 MB Listen Download
MP3 16000 Hz 31.25 kbits/sec 16.13 MB Listen Download
Audio Interchange File Format (AIFF) 1.34 Mbits/sec 711.46 MB Listen Download
Audio Interchange File Format (AIFF) 689.08 kbits/sec 355.73 MB Listen Download
Audio Interchange File Format (AIFF) 250.0 kbits/sec 129.06 MB Listen Download
Advanced Audio Coding (AAC) 44100 Hz 126.37 kbits/sec 65.24 MB Listen Download
Advanced Audio Coding (AAC) 22050 Hz 63.2 kbits/sec 32.63 MB Listen Download
Advanced Audio Coding (AAC) 16000 Hz 31.77 kbits/sec 16.40 MB Listen Download
RealAudio 582.02 kbits/sec 300.46 MB View Download Stream
RealAudio 95.82 kbits/sec 49.47 MB View Download Stream
RealAudio 32.02 kbits/sec 16.53 MB View Download Stream
RealMedia 877.44 kbits/sec 454.36 MB View Download Stream
RealMedia 736.33 kbits/sec 381.29 MB View Download Stream
RealMedia 185.57 kbits/sec 96.10 MB View Download Stream
Windows Media Video (for download) 476.64 kbits/sec 246.82 MB View Download
Windows Media Video (for streaming) 447.16 kbits/sec 231.55 MB View Download Stream
Windows Media Video (for download) 440.81 kbits/sec 228.26 MB View Download
Windows Media Video (for streaming) 187.01 kbits/sec 96.84 MB View Download Stream
Windows Media Video (for download) 308.56 kbits/sec 159.78 MB View Download
Windows Media Video (for streaming) 195.82 kbits/sec 101.40 MB View Download Stream
Auto * (Allows browser to choose a format it supports)